CREATOR WORKFLOW

How to make a claim check sheet for a product video ad

List what your ad says and implies, match each measurable claim to evidence, and revise the script when the evidence is narrower.

By Colquhoun Studio editorial ·

Write down what viewers are being asked to believe

Make a small table with columns for timestamp, claim, evidence, and decision. Add the narration and on-screen words. Then watch with the sound off and note what the pictures suggest. If a tabletop organizer appears to hold six large binders but the real demonstration uses two, record that visual implication even if the script never mentions capacity.

Match the evidence to the exact claim

In its U.S. advertising substantiation policy, the FTC says advertisers need a reasonable basis before publishing objective claims, including claims people infer from the ad. A specification can support a dimension for the exact product model. It does not show that the item fits every desk. Start with the claim and check whether the source supports its scope, not just a related fact. Reference: https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/ftc-policy-statement-regarding-advertising-substantiation

Narrow a line when the source is narrower

Imagine your evidence is the manufacturer’s dimensions and a recording showing two specific binders fitting in the organizer. “Shown with two 2-inch binders” describes the shot. “Fits all standard binders” goes beyond it. Change the line and the graphic, or leave the claim out. If you need an exact performance or comparative claim, do not treat a single take or a few customer comments as a substitute for suitable evidence.

Check cuts, timers, and labels for an unintended promise

Suppose the ad cuts from a pile of parts directly to a finished organizer while a stopwatch reads 30 seconds. A viewer may take that as an assembly time claim, even if you meant the timer as decoration. Remove the timer unless you can support the timing it suggests. When a condition matters, put it close enough to the relevant claim that people can read it while the claim is visible.

Review the finished file against the sheet

Use the exported video, not just the script. Verify each recorded timestamp and note which version you checked. Save the evidence with the asset version so a later editor can tell which model or setup it applies to. Repeat the check whenever an offer, product version, visual, or comparative claim changes. The sheet is a production check, not a substitute for legal review.